Percent Off vs. Dollar Off: Which Discount Saves More?

Compare a percentage discount with a fixed dollar-off coupon using the break-even price. Includes a quick rule, worked comparisons and a reference table.

You have two offers: 20% off, or $15 off. Which one saves more? The answer depends entirely on how much you are spending – and there is a simple way to find the tipping point.

The Difference Between Percent Off and Dollar Off

  • Percent off scales with the price. 20% off saves $4 on $20 but $40 on $200.
  • Dollar off is fixed. $15 off saves $15 whether you spend $20 or $200 (as long as any minimum spend is met).

The Break-Even Price

The two offers save the same amount at exactly one price:

Break-even price Break-Even Price = Dollar Amount ÷ (Percentage ÷ 100)

For 20% off vs. $15 off: $15 ÷ 0.20 = $75. Spend more than $75 and the percentage wins; spend less and the dollar amount wins.

Break-Even Table

Spend above this amount and the percentage discount saves more
Dollar offvs. 10% offvs. 15% offvs. 20% offvs. 25% offvs. 30% off
$5 off $50$33.33$25$20$16.67
$10 off $100$66.67$50$40$33.33
$15 off $150$100$75$60$50
$20 off $200$133.33$100$80$66.67
$25 off $250$166.67$125$100$83.33

Values that do not divide evenly are rounded to the nearest cent.

Worked Comparisons

A $60 basket: 20% off or $15 off?

20% off saves $12; $15 off saves $15. $15 off wins by $3.

A $140 order: 25% off or $30 off?

25% off saves $35; $30 off saves $30. 25% off wins by $5. (Break-even: $30 ÷ 0.25 = $120.)

A $45 item: 10% off or $5 off?

10% off saves $4.50; $5 off saves $5. $5 off wins by $0.50.

Check the Fine Print

  • Minimum spend. “$15 off $75” is useless on a $60 order.
  • Maximum discount. “20% off, up to $25” stops growing above $125.
  • Exclusions. Sale items, gift cards and some brands are often excluded from the eligible total.
  • Stacking. If both offers can be combined, apply the percentage first – see stacked discounts.

The coupon calculator handles minimum spends and caps, and picks the better coupon for your exact order.

Every example on this page was calculated with the same engine as our calculators and checked against the formulas shown. See our editorial policy.

Related Guides

  • Guide · 5 min read

    How stacked discounts work

    How to calculate two or more discounts applied one after another, why the total is less than the sum, and whether the order of the discounts matters.

  • Guide · 6 min read

    How to calculate percent off

    Learn how to calculate percent off a price three ways – the two-step method, the multiplier method and mental shortcuts – with worked examples and common mistakes.

  • Guide · 5 min read

    Sales tax and discounts

    How discounts and sales tax interact, why store and manufacturer coupons can be taxed differently, and how to calculate your checkout total either way.